The Growth Framework IG Follow
Money

He sold everything after a 15% fall. What went wrong?

A hypothetical but familiar story: an investor panics during a sharp PSX drop, sells everything, and then watches from the sidelines. The mistake was made long before the sale.

· 5 min read · By Waseem Raja

This is a hypothetical example, built from a common pattern. The names and numbers are illustrative.

The situation

Hamza, 32, works in Islamabad. Two years ago he started investing 20,000 PKR a month in a handful of PSX shares. His portfolio grew to about 600,000 PKR, and he checked it every evening.

Then the market fell sharply over three weeks. News channels talked about political uncertainty. His WhatsApp groups were full of warnings. His portfolio dropped to about 510,000 PKR, a fall of 15%.

The decision

One evening, after watching his balance fall again, Hamza sold everything. "I will buy back when things settle," he told himself. The relief was immediate.

Over the following months the market recovered part of the fall. Hamza did not buy back. Every rise felt like it might be a trap, and every dip felt like the start of another crash. A year later his money was still sitting in his bank account.

What was misunderstood

Hamza thought his problem was the market fall. His real problem was that he never decided in advance how he would respond to one.

  • He treated money he might need in the near future and long-term money the same way.
  • He had no written rule for what a fall should trigger.
  • He confused a temporary price drop with a permanent loss. Selling made the loss permanent.
  • He thought selling was one decision. It was two: when to get out, and when to get back in. The second is usually harder.

The principle

Decide your response to volatility before it happens, while you are calm.

The reasoning behind it

Established: stock markets, including the PSX, regularly go through sharp falls. Prices of individual shares can fall much further, and some never recover. Volatility is a normal feature of owning shares, not a sign that something unusual is happening.

Established: research in behavioural finance has found that many individual investors earn lower returns than the funds or markets they invest in, partly because they buy after rises and sell after falls. Studies of fund flows in several countries show this "behaviour gap", though its size varies by study and period.

Established: people tend to feel losses more strongly than equal gains. Psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky called this loss aversion. A falling balance checked every day creates many small painful moments, which increases the urge to act.

Interpretation: if your plan depends on staying calm during a fall, the plan should make calm easier. Rules written in advance, and less frequent checking, are practical ways to do that.

A better approach

  1. Separate the money. Money needed within about three years, and the emergency fund, should not be in shares. Only long-term money belongs there.
  2. Write a volatility rule. For example: "A market fall of up to 30% does not change my plan. I will review my holdings, not sell them by default." The number is a personal choice, not a recommendation.
  3. Separate the business from the price. In a fall, ask whether anything changed in the companies you own: profits, debt, management. If the business is still sound, the price drop alone is not a reason to sell. If the business has truly worsened, that is a separate, valid reason.
  4. Check less often. Reviewing monthly or quarterly instead of daily reduces emotional pressure without making you less informed about what matters.
  5. Keep investing on schedule if your situation has not changed. Regular monthly investing means you buy more shares when prices are lower.

Three practical lessons

  1. A fall you planned for is uncomfortable. A fall you did not plan for is dangerous.
  2. Selling is easy. Getting back in is the hard part. If you exit, you need a written re-entry rule too.
  3. Your time horizon is your protection. Money you will not need for many years can afford to wait; money you need soon cannot.

One action to try

Write three lines and keep them with your investment records: "My investing money is for ____ (goal), needed in ____ years. If the market falls by ____%, I will ____. I review my portfolio every ____."

Principle

Make your decisions on calm days, so you do not have to make them on frightening ones.

Educational content only. Not financial advice or a recommendation to buy, hold or sell any security. Share prices can fall and may not recover. Past market recoveries do not guarantee future ones.

Sources

  1. Kahneman D, Tversky A (1979). Prospect theory: an analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica
  2. Morningstar, Mind the Gap annual studies of investor returns versus fund returns
  3. Barber BM, Odean T (2000). Trading is hazardous to your wealth. Journal of Finance

Educational content only. This is not medical or financial advice. Check facts with qualified professionals before you act.